Absolutely, the main purpose of this language movement is to reduce stigma, so the more prevalent it becomes, the more comfortable people become in hearing and reading it. Harmful written and spoken identity-first language does one of three things:
1) Harmful language teaches listeners who have never heard it before that the language is okay to use.
Ex: Pointing and saying “that addict over there” to a child.
2) Harmful language reaffirms to listeners who have already heard it that it is still okay to use.
Ex: The R-word (“retarded”) has persisted for decades despite strong efforts to remove it from language for the obvious slur that it is. Why? Because people use it every day in jokes, and to describe things other than a mental illness.
3) Harmful language, regardless of your intent, signals information about the speaker. Harmful language acts as a signal that you do not view the person you are describing as a human being.
Ex: Three friends, Person A, Person B, and Person C, are approaching an intoxicated person on a narrow sidewalk, head-on, early in the afternoon. Person A is recovering from alcoholism, but her friends don’t know it. Person B drinks socially, but openly stigmatizes people with alcohol problems. Person C drinks socially, has limited experiences with anyone with alcoholism.
Person C, quietly: “Should we cross?”
Person A, “No, it’s fine.”
Person B, “Do what you want, I’m crossing. I don’t want to smell that drunk.”
(Persons C & B cross the street.)
Here, Person B’s language acts as a signal to Person C. Yes, Person C stigmatizes the intoxicated person by crossing the street, but Person C feels justified in the reaction through her solidarity with Person B. Person C is more likely to say something similar in the future.
Person B’s language acts as a red flag to Person A. Person A will likely never feel safe opening up around Person B, and Person A learns that if the tables were turned, Person B, or someone like Person B, may not treat Person A much better than Person B treated the intoxicated person.